Sunday, December 15, 2013

Social Determinism and the Origins of Braille and Sign Language

Braille:
         The Braille system was invented by Louis Braille at the age of 15 in 1824 (Foulke 169). The first implementation of the 6-dot Braille system evolved from a night writing code used to send military messages that could be read on the battlefield when no light source was present called “Ecriture Nocturne,” underscoring the already discovered, albeit not refined, method of utilizing raised print letters to enable blind people to read independently (National Braille Week Exhibition 2013). Louis Braille was a victim of blindness from the age of three and was awarded a scholarship to the Royal Institution for Blind Youth in Paris where his desire to read more books increased and lead him to experiment better ways to do just that (National Braille Week Exhibition 2013). Thus, the Braille system was born out of need: social determinism. Although the Braille is now known to be a fully equipped tactile reading and writing system, the first paper published by Louis Braille was Music and Plain Songs by Means of Dots for Use by the Blind (National Braille Week Exhibition 2013). Music has a very different form of reading and writing, for it requires a sense of structure and methodology to communicate pauses and beats. Perhaps the level of eloquence and structure necessitated to write music in Braille allowed for further inquiry into its use as a tool for more diversified forms of communication.

Sign Language:
            Sign language is not simply pantomime, but rather a language that possesses structural properties that have evolved independently of spoken languages. It requires verbal agreement, aspectual marking, and has a system for forming agglutinative classifiers (Sign Language). Although the earliest written record of a sign language can be dated back to the fifth century BC, it was not until the 1960’s that sign language was formally researched in the United States under Stokoe (Crasborn). American Sign Language (ASL) was born only after structured research into sign language as a communicative tool for the deaf people. Thus, sign language as a text technology that requires instruction is relatively new.

The Connection:
ASL, similar to Braille, was born out of need. However, ASL is unique such that sign language had already existed prior to its formalization. Social determinism may have played a factor in birthing sign language, but technological determinism, defined as formalized research and best practices, played a role in structuring its use for dissemination, resulting in the advent of ASL. The origins of Braille and ASL uncovers the underlying nature of disseminating a given text technology that the masses have affinity towards, at least in respect to text technologies aimed at enabling communication for the disabled. Whereas Braille began as a result of focused aim at creating a reading and writing system, sign language evolved naturally for centuries. Not until sign language was recognized as a discipline did ASL become more widespread. This suggests that dissemination of a text technology requires a level of instruction and standardization. In turn, this requires the recognition of a tool’s value followed by its formal research.   Furthermore, the fact that Braille was formalized earlier implies that it had a greater perceived value in society.  As proposed earlier, the eloquence of Braille allowed for further exploration in its applicability to solve communication issues for blind people. Perhaps the eloquence of research by “experts” provides credibility to a given text technology. It seems as though formalization and eloquence are high criterion for continued exploration in alternative communication methods for the disabled.

1.       Crasborn, Onno. "Phonetic and phonological distinctions in sign languages." Holland Institute of Generative Linguistics. (2000): 1-20. Web. 15 Dec. 2013. <http://www.sign-lang.uni-hamburg.de/intersign/internal/vdhulst2.pdf>Foulke, Emerson. "5. Reading braille." Tactual perception: A sourcebook(1982): 168.
2.       "National Braille Week Exhibition 2013." Braille Facts. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 Dec. 2013. <http://www.nationalbrailleweek.org/page/braille-facts>.

3.       "Sign Language." WFD World Federation of the Deaf. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 Dec. 2013. <http://wfdeaf.org/human-rights/crpd/sign-language>.

No comments:

Post a Comment